An expert writes:
“The video titled ‘The Stalkers,’ available at this link [see below], is material evidence that lays the ground for a CBI investigation into this totally illegal surveillance of a young woman and her associates — and the roles of Amit Shah, Narendra Modi, G. L. Singhal, and some others.
“Allowing for some possible transcription errors, the audio recordings do reveal a great deal that is of public interest.
“It is significant that Amit Shah (as Prashant Bhushan pointed out in a CNN-IBN panel discussion on Monday, November 19, 2013) has so far not denied it is his voice in the recordings, and also that Modi has so far chosen not to make a statement about this affair.
“Authentication of the audio recordings should be a simple and straightforward task. Since the recordings are in the custody of the CBI and were handed over to the agency by Singhal, the preponderance of probability is that the recordings are authentic.
“They reveal Amit Shah’s, and the State’s, extraordinary obsession with the movements of the young woman and a close nexus with ‘Saheb’, who has his independent sources of information and comes up with leads that put a good deal of pressure on Shah.
“It is also clear from Shah’s hands-on involvement, his oral instructions to Singhal, and Singhal’s conversations at the instance of Shah with some other police officers, that the intensive surveillance by those supposed to be involved in anti-terrorism activities is illegal — there can be no doubt about this.
“Circumstantial and external evidence (from the father of the young woman) indicate that ‘Saheb’ is Narendra Modi. Amit Shah feeds the leads he periodically receives from ‘Saheb’ into the illegal surveillance operations conducted by Singhal. Through their public statements, the young woman’s father, and indeed the BJP, have come close to confirming that ‘Saheb’ is Modi.
“There is solid material here for a criminal investigation and prosecution.”
[Scroll down for full transcript.]